top of page

Episode 37 | Elijah Lewis, Merrimack, New Hampshire & Unsolved Cases Of The Granite State

Writer's picture: Anngelle WoodAnngelle Wood

Elijah Lewis was five years old when he went missing from his mother's house in Merrimack, New Hampshire in October 2021.

In October of 2021, a five year old boy was reported missing in Merrimack, New Hampshire after he hadn't been seen for over a month. Any missing child is an emergency. Or should be. Except his mother, whose custody he had been in for just over a year, wasn't who reported him missing.

Why was Elijah Lewis even living with his mother at the time? And why did she want him gone? This is a difficult story about violence against a child. I have a lot of questions. I share information about other unsolved New Hampshire cases:

Megan Jimenez, age 2 ½ years Murdered June 15, 1989, Merrimack NH Unsolved homicide


Anne Psaradelis and Diane Compagna, age 15 years old Missing: July 12, 1973 leaving Hampton Beach for home in Merrimack, NH Found: September 29, 1973 in the woods off of New Boston Road in Candia, NH Unsolved double homicide


Maura Murray Missing: February 9, 2004, North Haverhill, NH Maura has not been found

Davyn Hanson, age 15 Missing: Oct 14, 2022, Portsmouth, NH Davyn has not been found Harmony Montgomery, 5 when she went missing Missing: Oct 1, 2019, Manchester, NH Missing, presumed dead

Tammy Belanger, age 8 Missing: November 13, 1984, Exeter, NH Tammy has not been found


Paul Herlihy, age 50 Found: August 27, 2003, Milford, NH Unsolved homicide Roberta “Bobbie” Miller and dog, Scout Found: November 1, 2010, Gilford, NH Unsolved homicide


Domingo Valdes Found: June 14, 1974, Pelham, NH Unsolved homicide Stella Bolton and James J. Moore Found: February 16, 1991, Portsmouth, NH Unsolved double homicide New Hampshire Cold Case Tip Form https://business.nh.gov/ColdCaseTips/Tip.aspx If you need to report information that is of an emergency nature, please contact the New Hampshire State Police toll free at (800) 525-5555 or call your local police/sheriff department. The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) https://www.missingkids.org


Sources below.

Thank you for listening. I wish you a calm and peaceful holiday season. See you in January.




Sources

National Center for Missing & Exploited Children https://www.missingkids.org/ourwork/impact


NH DOJ: Elijah Lewis


NY Post: Elijah Lewis died of violence, neglect


WMUR Channel 9, Manchester, NH: Elijah Lewis’ mother arraigned


NBC Boston: Elijah Lewis autopsy



WCVB Channel 5, Boston: Elijah Lewis case: The cell phone that broke the case



Boston Globe: Autopsy findings


NBC News Boston: Neighbors speak about Elijah Lewis discovery


WMUR Channel 9, Manchester, NH Dauphinais Hearings


Indepthnh.org: Boyfriend in Elijah Lewis case pleads guilty


Patriot Ledger: Joseph Stapf cops a plea in Elijah’s murder


CBS News Boston: Missing Boy Elijah Lewis


MassLive: Mother of Elijah Lewis pleads not guilty to charges as search continues for missing New Hampshire boy


CBS News: Alexey Brayman charged with using Merrimack, New Hampshire home in Russian smuggling ring https://www.cbsnews.com/boston/news/alexey-brayman-merrimack-new-hampshire-home-russian-smuggling-ring-arrests/


Town & Country magazine, Sex Trafficker’s house in NH


©2025 Crime of the Truest Kind & Anngelle Wood Media
All Rights Reserved

bottom of page